No Tears Over State Nurse Ousters

cficarebody.jpg

TTLA didn't expect James Underdown, executive director of the Center for Inquiry - Los Angeles, to shed any tears over this week's major shake-up of the California Board of Registered Nursing.

(See, "Schwarzenegger Replaces Most of State Nursing Board," by the L.A. Times and ProPublica.)

Underdown and other members of the CFI have long been at odds with the Board regarding its oversight of mandatory continuing education programs for nurses.

"This house cleaning of the CBRN may be long overdue," Underdown e-mailed TTLA yesterday. "The Independent Investigations Group at the Center for Inquiry has been battling the nursing board for over 4 years to remove pseudo-science from the California nursing's continuing education system."

CFI'ers say they first sought to assist the CBRN; to help that body understand that some of the courses in the nurses' catalogs didn't fit the scientific rigor that the Board's own standards demand. After failing to make progress in this advocacy role, the CFI decided, essentially, if you can't beat 'em, join 'em.

So on April 5, 2009, on a Sunday mid-morning that's church time for some, and brunch time for others, the CFI hosted a program titled, "Feng Shui for Home Care Providers."

The presentation included all manner of the absurd, from provocateur Underdown in a white shirt stained with fake theatrical blood, talking about using entrails in order to divine illness; to a section devoted to the importance of a made-up word that organizers said they couldn't find a meaning for in any language; to the feng shui portion from the title, during which a demonstration purported to show that by following those principles, a nurse would wind up physically separated from a patient, stuck on the opposite side of a hospital room.

According to the CFI, all of the above had been approved for continuing education credit. That approval was then rescinded in a letter dated March 27. Underdown and company believe the rescinding came after the CFI started publicizing the course -- which was done in a manner making the group's disdain for the Board clear.

cficarelecturebody.jpg Underdown, previously mentioned in this blog here and here -- plus here in this vintage OC Weekly cover story -- added this to his email:

"For over 4 years, the former Board and staff have obstinately refused to examine shoddy continuing education standards for California nurses."

And then he pasted these words from Tuesday's L.A. Times:

"When Ruth Ann Terry and her assistant executive officer, Heidi Goodman, say in their an e-mail to all board staff,

"'Ruth and I are aware of the grim picture painted by this article,'" they wrote, "'however, the board members, managers and supervisors know that you work very hard to carry out the mission of the board to protect the healthcare consumers in California and we appreciate all that you do.'"

"I have to laugh," Underdown's email concluded. "The classes being taught to professional nurses are well outside the world of acceptable science. The new board better take a hard look at more than just disciplinary issues. There are fundamental problems with what nurses are being taught about science and how the body functions."

More on this topic to come -- TTLA has a file to get through with photos, video, a letter, and various interviews with April 5 attendees.

Pictured above -- a blank copy of the certificate that "CFICare (California Foundation for Institutional Care)" planned to give to nurses who completed the course. By the way, the CFICare logo -- it looks from afar like a sun with solar flare lines radiating out. Up close, it's sperm, not rays, bearing down on an egg, not from a star. Plus, directly above, a photo from the would-be course.

Images courtesy Center for Inquiry - Los Angeles

Comments

Wow. I am left to wonder what the nurses thought of the "training."

This is a very interesting restructuring. But I have to ask, what type of pseudo-science are they exactly teaching at these continual training programs?

LaLand is a new age capital, so this only figures. If it's not the right wing christians, it's the empty headed liberals with their gurus. God help- oh, wait!

Thank you each for your comments...

I have interviews on file with a couple of the nurses - who were also CFI fans, if memory serves -- who were in attendance that Sunday. As time permits, I'll work to get some of their words up in a follow-up post...

Also, here's the URL from a CFI press release:

http://iigwest.com/blog/2009/04/03/california-nursing-board-battles-the-pro-science-independent-investigations-group/

If you go there, you'll see that "Therapeutic Touch" is the name of one accredited course in particular that the CFI objected to. Also at that URL, you'll find the made-up word TTLA referred to this morning, plus... a snake oil reference.

-- TTLA

When we taught our (once certified) Feng Shui for Home Practitioners class, the nurses who were in attendance were appalled that such a course had been certified by the Board.

The IIG investigation started when we learned of a Therapeutic Touch class being taught for continuing education credit for nurses. Therapeutic touch claims that a practitioner manipulates and re-alligns an alleged energy field over the patient. No actual touching is involved.

This claim does not jibe with modern science.

See www.iigwest.org for more...

Leave a comment

Please review KCET.org's Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
SoCal Connected

About Think Tank LA

Think Tank L.A. is a slow-boil chronicling of the goings-on at policy centers, research institutions, and the like in and around the Southland – and beyond. The blog covers the tanks themselves, the people who work at them, and the big ideas so often born at tanks. It's written by Jeremy Rosenberg

More KCET Local Blogs

404 City
Read Ophelia Chong's latest post, Is That You?

Blur + Sharpen
Read Holly Willis's latest post, Diana Thater: Between Science and Magic

Cakewalk
Read Erin Aubry Kaplan's latest post, Power to
the People

City of Angles
Read Brian Doherty's latest post, The City Ax Begins to Cut

The Guest Room
Read Anthea Raymond's latest post, Remembering Brendan Mullen

Movie Miento
Read Adolfo Guzman-Lopez's latest post, Radiate

Pixeltown
Read Laura Swanson's latest post, Get to Know Ophelia Chong

The Other Room
Read Kevin Ferguson's latest post, Ex-Wetlands

Where We Are
Read D.J. Waldie's latest post, Neighbors

See More Recent Blog Posts

Recent Comments

Tell Us

Got something to say? Got an idea that would make a great local story, or want to share an article or blog post you find interesting? Tell us about it.

Send Feedback

E-Newsletter Signup

Get great content from KCET straight to your inbox. Sign up for our monthly e-mail featuring upcoming KCET programming, events, ticket giveaways and web-only highlights.

Signup Form

Show Your Support

Like what you see? Donate now to support local, intelligent, independent stories. We appreciate your support.

Donate